Compare the way two TV dramas construct representation of
gender.
All TV dramas have different characters shown to the
audience in different ways, whether they are a humorous character or where just
an evil manipulative character, the characters personality and how they are
represented to the audience can vary very much in TV dramas to create the
scene. The two TV dramas I will be looking at are Hustle and The killing. Both
show large differences but again similarities to show the representation of the
gender in the TV drama.
Camera shot play a key part of any type of TV to show the
audience who is being watched and maybe why. In the TV drama Hustle the drama
begins with a medium close up of the man Dexter, showing the glorious gold
surrounding him in his large office. A stereotypical women ‘Blonde and blue
eyes’ struts in but only to be able to hear her footsteps to but the camera is
still on Dexter. This shows that the her as a stereotypical woman in heels,
ready for business, but won’t show her as it leave the audience in suspense in
who is making their way to the desk. A cut in extreme close up of the business
card saying ‘Gold Hard Cash’ is shown for about 3 seconds, then the camera
slowly makes its way up to the ‘sexy blonde’s’ face. The slow movement of the
character represents the sexual attraction Dexter has towards women that come
to his office as he pays a lot of interest towards her and delicately looks up
the top half of her body and finally her face is revealed. Once the woman’s
face is revealed the camera is automatically put back on Dexter, a medium close
up with his wide eyes showing, as the camera hovers backwards and forwards/
zooming in and out. This represents almost a cartoon figure of a man finding an
attractive lady very appealing. As If eyes are about to fall out. The camera
then being put back on the women as she knows Dexter is attracted to her, she
using her looks at her potential and raising her eye brows, the camera is on a
medium close up. This is to show the audience how attractive she really is so they
can understand the reaction of Dexter. He then goes into a fantasy dream where
the camera shot is a point of view shot, this is as if Dexter is watching over
her as she rolls around in the ruffled silky gold fabric. This shot represents
the how men are supposedly higher up than women but is as the images of her are
repeated next to each other with her smiling at the camera, it shows that the
attractive women has taken Dexter’s gold and won her status over his. Her
smiling represents she knows how easily she can get Dexter wrapped round her
little finger. The scene ends in a medium close up shot of both characters
separately, and then a mid-shot of the other women. This represents the power
of the stereo typical beautiful women can use their looks to overcome other
women’s status’ to get where they want in life. As the other woman chucks her
pen down it shows she has no competition against her purely because she has no
way of beating her.
However in the other TV drama I looked at similar/ or the
same camera shots were used but in very different ways. In The Killing the
camera view begins with a point of view shot, this is used almost the whole way
through the clip. Unlike Hustle which point of view shot was used as a man
fantasying over the women and the women taking charge knowing her looks are at
her advantage to win her job. The Killing’s point of view shot is to set the
eerie atmosphere, that someone or something is watching her; leading tension
the whole way through the clip. The beginning of the clips begins with a
mid-shot point of view as the women looks very confused in what exactly is
going to happen. The camera slowly moves backwards as she walks. The slow
movements of the camera represent the danger she is letting herself in for. The
next shot is a wide shot this but the camera is angle on the floor looking up
at her through the hanging meat. This represents that trouble is on its way, as
something is looking through dead meat in a point of view shot, but her not
looking over at the camera, therefore she is unable to see the person. This
shows the advantage the other person has compared to the woman. Almost as if
she should be crying out for help by this point. The angle being focused below
her represents her being higher up and fierce in what is going to happen next.
As the shot moves to a behind shoulder shot, of the trolley being shoved at
her, this shows the strength of the other person has as she was almost knocked
over it. But then again as she pushing the trolley aside and with even more strength,
show the anger of her at this point. She behind shoulder shot is used whilst
running as the camera shakes from side to side to create the effect to the
audience that they are running behind, almost part of the chase. The clear shot
of the man dressed in all black and showing that she cannot catch up with him
shows that men are dominating and she is struggling as a woman. As they make
their way into the club a point of view shot is done to show the panic of the
search to find this man. But the extreme close up of other people’s faces in
the club represent the loosing of the women. But as she continues and a
mid-shot of the mysterious man dressed in black shows that she is catching up
and winning her higher dependence over the man. As she continues to run a what
looks like an abandoned part of the club and wide shot of the women down a
corridor is shown. The shot emphasises the how long the corridor actually is
and this represents the emphasis of the chance of her winning over the man.
However the extreme close up cut in of the black door handle, as she find a
door to go through, creates the tension of the scene. Creating the audience to
think ‘has she finally found him’. The camera is on the handle for about 3-5
seconds, this creates tensions to what could be lurking behind the door. The
shot represents how long she may have long to live, or how long she has until
she has caught the hooded man. The shot with wide shot with both characters in
show the man in standing higher up than the women. As he hits her round the
head, the camera hasn’t moved, and she falls to the ground. The camera shot
again doesn’t move. This shows that the man has won the chase, and he is more
dominant than the women. It represents no matter what’s reinforced earlier on
men will always have high ground/ be more dominant than women in society.
Something else that is important in TV dramas is mise en
scene. This includes the characters, what they wear, what makeup etc. In the
hustle Dexter the man is shown as a typical cockney business man. His fake
cockney accent represents he has tried hard to get where he is today. Maybe
suggesting when he was younger he was not a typical ‘ladies’ man’ and wasn’t
accepted by the people he knew. So now he is a ‘try hard’ putting on a strong
cockney accent to fit his business character, which he thinks would be more
appealing for women. He wears a purple Shirt with gold tie, with quite a few
gold accessories on him e.g. earring, ring, watch. This represents his wealth, however the
clashing in colours of purple and gold represent the clashing of his cheap
looking (covered in cheap looking gold jewellery e.g. watch, ring, earring.) to
what his business actually is, he earns a lot of money but what he wear clashes
being he looks cheap (identity and business clashes). He is also bald which
doesn’t seem very appealing to women at all; this could show the ageing of
himself. With a grey/black beard on his chin. His shows he’s not as young as he
makes out by going after younger women. He has no respect for women really, as
he hasn’t even spoke to the attractive women Emma. Yet he pays a lot of
interest for her. However with the other women in office he doesn’t even look
at her when he asks for a cup of tea. Is demanding and rude.
Ciara Singleton, Unfinished.
Relevant response showing mostly accurate use of terminology. Consistent textual evidence from the extract, with a range of examples offered from the media texts. Thoughtful consideration of alternative meanings possibly constructed from technical choices made. Analysis - 14, Examples - 15, Terminology - 6 (Level 3). Aim for more specific examples of technical choices, with imaginative and detailed interpretations of how gender is constructed. Refer to camera position and movement as well as actor positioning. Consider lighting, colour and visual effects. Relate to the context of the relevant TV drama, referring to comparable current and historical dramas, eg. criminal-led drama, female detective-led drama. How do these fit into the genre as a whole in either confirming or subverting gender stereotypes? Ms Keenan
ReplyDeleteCiara - there should be a Cutting It essay and a Some Girls essay on here by now? Please see me.
ReplyDeleteWhere is the Soap Opera Q&A homework?
ReplyDelete